When winter comes, cozy boots are essential, and two brands often compared are Uggs and Bearpaw. While both offer warmth and style, they differ in terms of materials, comfort, durability, and price. Below, we provide an in-depth comparison to help you decide which brand is best for your needs.
Design and Appearance

Both Uggs and Bearpaw boots feature a similar look, with suede exteriors and a cozy shearling-lined interior. Certain styles of both brands, like the ones reviewed, include a button detail that allows the boots to fold over. However, there is a key difference in how well the boots maintain their shape:
- Uggs hold their structure beautifully, staying upright even after months of wear.
- Bearpaw boots, on the other hand, tend to sag over time. Initially stiff, they quickly lose their upright shape, which may not appeal to everyone.
In terms of style, the boots are nearly identical in height and design, but Bearpaw boots appear slightly chunkier. Uggs also offer more calf space, making them a better choice for individuals with wider calves.
Materials and Comfort

The difference in materials plays a significant role in the performance and feel of these boots:
- Uggs use genuine sheepskin for the exterior and a thick, plush sheepskin lining. The fur feels fuller, softer, and of higher quality.
- Bearpaw boots use cow suede for the exterior and a wool blend lining. While warm, the lining is less fluffy and doesn’t provide the same luxurious feel as Uggs.
The lighter weight of Uggs is another factor to consider. They feel effortless to walk in, while Bearpaw boots are heavier, which some may find less comfortable for extended use.
Sizing

Sizing is an important consideration when choosing between these two brands:
- Uggs: These run slightly big but fit well once the lining compresses. If you’re between sizes or unsure, trying on a size down may be a good idea.
- Bearpaw: These boots run significantly larger. It’s recommended to size down, especially since they tend to stretch with wear. For instance, a size 9 Bearpaw may feel more like a 10, while Uggs in the same size provide a more snug fit.
Durability

Durability is where Uggs justify their higher price tag. After months of wear:
- Uggs retain their structure, with no significant creasing or flattening along the back or sides.
- Bearpaw boots are prone to creasing and sagging. The sides and back may show noticeable wear, and the fur lining becomes matted more quickly.
However, both brands have sturdy soles that remain in good condition over time, showing minimal wear on the treads.
Care and Maintenance
Maintaining winter boots can be a challenge, especially with lighter colors, but Uggs have a clear advantage here:
- Uggs offer a specialized care kit that includes cleaning soap, a brush, a deodorizing spray, and a water-and-stain protector. This kit helps extend the boots’ lifespan and keeps them looking fresh.
- Bearpaw does not provide a comparable care kit, so maintaining their boots requires external products and extra effort.
Price and Value
One of the biggest distinctions between these brands is the price:
- Uggs: With prices starting around $175, they are a premium investment. However, their superior materials and durability mean you’re likely to get more use out of them.
- Bearpaw: At $70–$80, these are significantly more affordable, offering good quality for the price. While they may not last as long as Uggs, they’re still warm, comfortable, and functional.
Overall Performance
So, are Uggs worth the extra cost? Based on the comparison:
- Uggs: Their premium sheepskin lining, lightweight feel, and ability to maintain their shape make them a luxurious choice. They’re ideal for those willing to invest in long-term quality.
- Bearpaw: For budget-conscious buyers, Bearpaw boots offer excellent warmth and functionality. They’re a solid alternative if you’re not ready to splurge on Uggs.
Final Verdict
If comfort, quality, and durability are your priorities, Uggs are the clear winner. They not only feel better on your feet but also hold up better over time. However, if you’re looking for an affordable, stylish boot that will keep your feet warm through the colder months, Bearpaw boots are an excellent choice. Both brands cater to different needs and budgets, so the best choice depends on what you value most in your footwear.